Does Seattle shun startup failure?
29
Oct
2009
Tonight I attended the UW CSE Annual Industrial Affiliates Meeting.
As I walked around, I bumped into familiar faces close to the UW CSE and Startup communities. I asked people “how are we doing on entrepreneurship coming out of the department?” Surprisingly, feedback from 3 people very close to the issue was “we’re not doing too well.” Common themes:
- Infrequent interaction between entrepreneurs, venture capital and the university
- UW CSE department seems to measure itself on students who progress into academia (vs. go off and start successful companies)
- Sense that Seattle’s community shuns failure
Wow, that’s depressing! But, if true, how can we overcome it?
At dinner in front of everyone, I had the chance to ask a panel of local VCs, “What are things we can do to advance entrepreneurship between the UW CSE and the Seattle community?”
Here’s a summary of responses (note: I’m paraphrasing very briefly from my limited iPhone notes)
- Cameron Myrvold, Ignition - the problem is cultural; compared to the silicon valley, historically the best people went to big companies vs. starting companies, and failure is still shunned.
- Bill McAleer, Voyager Capital - we need to do things that increase the risk tolerance. Things like the UW business plan competition helps
- Ron Howell, WRF Capital – everyone in the community needs to show up at events and actively participate
- Mark Ashida, OVP – agreed that the problem is cultural. In the silicon valley (where he worked for years) it is considered a positive career step to venture out of big companies and okay to fail vs. here where it is perceived as a negative. We need to work to change that perception
- Greg Gottesman, Madrona - we need to catalyze entrepreneurship, and he and Madrona are working on that, via a Y Combinator or Tech Stars type program currently under discussion, which will be sponsored by area VCs and involve industry veterans.
- Ed Lazowska, UW CSE – over the last 12 years, there has been positive change and progress and we need to continue that. The notion of an organization like Y Combinator here in Seattle is an excellent one that people should support
What do you think? Does Seattle have a cultural intolerance of failure that stifles entrepreneurship? And what are some concrete things the community can do to encourage entrepreneurship coming out of UW CSE?